FIRST MID BANCSHARES INC (FMBH)

Sector: Financials

    Home/Companies/FMBH/Annual Meeting

2026 Annual Meeting Analysis

FIRST MID BANCSHARES INC · Meeting: April 29, 2026

Policy v1.2high confidenceView Filing ↗
For informational purposes only. This AI-generated analysis applies a published voting policy to publicly available proxy filings. It does not constitute investment advice, proxy voting advice, or a solicitation of any kind. AI analysis may be incomplete or inaccurate — always review the actual filing and make your own independent decision.

Directors FOR

4

Directors AGAINST

0

Say on Pay

FOR

Auditor

FOR

Director Elections

Election of Directors

4 FOR
✓ FOR
J. Kyle McCurry

McCurry has served since 2021 and brings relevant banking and legal experience; FMBH's 3-year stock return of +59.8% outpaces the community bank benchmark QABA by +20.5 percentage points, well below the 65-point threshold required to trigger a negative vote, and no other policy concerns apply.

✓ FOR
Alex J. Melvin

Melvin joined the board in November 2025, placing him within the 24-month new-director exemption period, so the stock performance trigger does not apply; his extensive retail and real estate operating experience adds relevant skills to the board.

✓ FOR
Paul L. Palmby

Palmby has served since November 2024 and is within the 24-month new-director exemption period, so the stock performance trigger does not apply; his CEO experience at a publicly traded food company and prior community bank board service are relevant qualifications.

✓ FOR
Mary J. Westerhold

Westerhold has served since 2016 and is the designated audit committee financial expert; FMBH's 3-year stock return outperforms QABA by +20.5 percentage points, far short of the 65-point threshold needed to trigger a negative vote, and no other concerns apply.

All four director nominees pass the policy screens. FMBH's 3-year total shareholder return of +59.8% outperforms the community bank benchmark QABA (First Trust NASDAQ ABA Community Bank Index) by +20.5 percentage points, well below the 65-point underperformance threshold required to trigger a negative vote for strong-positive TSR companies. Two nominees (Melvin and Palmby) joined within the past 24 months and are exempt from the TSR trigger. No overboarding, attendance, independence, or familial relationship concerns were identified. The board discloses a skills matrix and includes a designated financial expert on the audit committee.

Say on Pay

✓ FOR

CEO

Joseph R. Dively

Total Comp

$2,109,337

Prior Support

97%%

The CEO received total compensation of $2,109,337 in 2025, which is reasonable for a CEO of a $1.1 billion market cap community bank; base salary of $543,400 represents approximately 26% of total compensation, with the remaining 74% being performance-based variable pay (cash incentive of $1,019,364 and stock awards of $514,272), comfortably exceeding the 50-60% variable pay requirement. The annual cash incentive plan uses multiple measurable financial metrics including net income, asset quality, efficiency ratio, and lines of business income with clear threshold and target levels, and payouts reflected strong 2025 performance — adjusted net income of $91.6 million exceeded the $81 million target. The company earned 97% shareholder support at the last Say on Pay vote in 2023, the stock has outperformed the community bank benchmark QABA over three years, and the company has a meaningful clawback policy in place, all of which support a FOR vote.

Auditor Ratification

✓ FOR

Auditor

Forvis Mazars, LLP

Tenure

20 yrs

Audit Fees

$622,250

Non-Audit Fees

$64,603

Non-audit fees (audit-related fees of $45,903 plus other fees of $18,700 totaling $64,603) represent approximately 10.4% of audit fees of $622,250, well below the 50% threshold that would raise independence concerns. Forvis Mazars has served since July 2005, giving a tenure of approximately 20 years, which is below the 25-year threshold that would trigger a negative vote. No material financial restatements were identified, and Forvis Mazars is a large national firm appropriate for a $1.1 billion market cap company.

Overall Assessment

The 2026 First Mid Bancshares annual meeting presents a clean ballot with no significant governance concerns: all four director nominees pass policy screens, the auditor relationship is appropriately sized with low non-audit fees and tenure below the concern threshold, and the executive compensation program features a strong variable-pay mix tied to clear financial performance goals with 97% prior shareholder support. There are no stockholder proposals on the ballot, and the company's stock has meaningfully outperformed the QABA community bank benchmark over the past three years.

Filing date: March 17, 2026·Policy v1.2·high confidence

Compensation Peer Group

16 companies disclosed in 2026 proxy filing

FMNBFarmers National Banc Corp.
FBKFB Financial Corporation
FCFFirst Commonwealth Financial Corporation
THFFFirst Financial Corporation
FSUNFirstSun Capital Bancorp
GABCGerman American Bancorp, Inc.
GSBCGreat Southern Bancorp, Inc.
HBTHBT Financial, Inc.
MOFGMidwest One Financial Group, Inc.
NICNicolet Bankshares, Inc.
OSBCOld Second Bancorp, Inc.
PRKPark National Corporation
PEBOPeoples Bancorp, Inc.
QCRHQCR Holdings, Inc.
RBCAARepublic Bancorp, Inc.
SYBTStock Yards Bancorp, Inc.